Consensual justice

the suicide of the right to a defense as a virtue

Views: 49

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.12709883

Keywords:

consensual justice, right to a defense, due process of law, contradictory proceeding

Abstract

The new model of consensual justice has been defended enthusiastically in doctrine, and, what is worse, in a fatalistic way, to the point that it is often heard that “consensual justice has come to stay”. This brief work will seek to demonstrate that this is exactly what supporters of consensual justice want: through seductive and fatalistic speeches, they want consensual justice to be accepted passively and unreflectively. The fact is that a more reflected and considered analysis of this new model of justice can only lead to a single conclusion: consensual justice, claiming to preserve the right to a defense, to a due process of law and a contradictory proceeding, treacherously eliminates these rights and guarantees of citizens in criminal proceedings.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Nadir Mazloum, Advocacia

Pós-Graduado lato sensu na Escola Paulista da Magistratura – Especialização em Direito Processual Penal. Advogado. Currículo Lattes: http://lattes.cnpq.br/2355549636052706

References

BELLAVISTA, Girolamo. Difesa giudiziaria penale. In: Enciclopedia del Diritto. vol. XII. Varese: Giuffré, 1964. p. 454-464.

CARNELUTTI, Francesco. Lições sobre o processo penal. vol. 1. Tradução: Francisco José Galvão Bruno. Campinas: Bookseller, 2004.

CARULLI, Nicola. La difesa dell’imputato. Nápoles: Eugenio Jovene, 1974.

CONSTANT, Benjamin. Escritos de política. Tradução: Eduardo Brandão. São Paulo: Martins Fontes, 2005.

DINACCI, Ugo. Saggi di diritto e procedura penale. Roma: Bulzoni, 1977.

FOSCHINI, Gaetano. Sistema del Diritto Processuale Penale. vol. I. 2. ed. Milão: Giuffrè, 1965.

GAROFALO, Rafaelle. Criminologia. Tradução: Julio de Mattos. São Paulo: Teixeira, 1893.

GRAZIANO, Silvestro. La difesa penale nell’istruttoria. 2. ed. Bolonha: Fratelli, 1913.

HÉLIE, Faustin. Traité de l’instruction criminelle. vol. 8. Paris: Charles-Hingray, 1858.

ORTOLAN, Joseph Louis Elzear. Éléments de droit penal. Tomo 2. Paris: Plon, 1875.

PASCAL, Blaise. Pensamentos. Tradução: Christian Lesage, Kirion, 2023.

RAND, Ayn. A revolta de Atlas. Tradução: Paulo Henrique Britto. São Paulo: Arqueiro, 2010.

Published

2024-08-27

How to Cite

Mazloum, N. (2024). Consensual justice: the suicide of the right to a defense as a virtue. Boletim IBCCRIM, 32(382), 29–31. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.12709883

Issue

Section

Dossiê: Desafios Atuais da Defesa Técnica (Pública e Privada)